Babylon
George Martin’s Grill Fire–Merrick
Harbor Crab Co.
Insignia / Lobster Mac & Cheese–
Nesconset
Karvers Grille
Landmark Diner
Maliblue Oyster Bar, Lobster Mac &
Cheese–Lido Beach
Robke’s Country Inn
Spiro’s Restaurant & Lounge
Zorn’s–Multiple Locations
MEATBALL
Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza–Multiple
Locations
Fattusco’s Gourmet
Iavarone Bros.–Multiple Locations
Joe’s Pizza and Pasta–Holbrook
Mario’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
Parmagianni
Piccolo’s Restaurant
Pizzatini
Robke’s Country Inn
Spiro’s Restaurant & Lounge
That Meetball Place
Tony Colombos
Villa Maria of Bethpage
Vincent’s Clam Bar–Westbury
Vito’s Ristorante & Pizzeria
MUSSELS
Claws Seafood Market
Corner Galley–Massapequa
Fattusco’s Gourmet Pizza
H2O Seafood Grill–Smithtown
Harbor Crab Company–Patchogue
Joe’s Crab Shack–Multiple Locations
Lobster Roll
Parmagianni
Peter’s Clam Bar
Popei’s Clam Bar–Bethpage
Porto Fino Restaurant–Huntington
Sea Basin Restaurant
Spiro’s Restaurant & Lounge
Star Island Grill
Storyville American Table
Vincent’s Clam Bar–Carle Place
Vito’s Ristorante & Pizzeria
Waterzooi Belgian Bistro
NACHOS
3 Amigo’s–East Northport
Applebee’s–Multiple Locations
Chili’s–Multiple Locations
Connolly Station Pub / Irish Nachos–
Malverne
Del Fuego–North
Don Ricardo’s–Babylon
El Coyote Loco
Green Cactus Mexican Grill–Multiple
Locations
Jonathan Scinto
K. Pacho–New Hyde Park
Kasey’s Kitchen & Cocktails–Rockville
Center
Library Cafe–Farmingdale
Miller’s Ale House–Multiple Locations
Moe’s Southwest Grill
Taco Joe’s–Massapequa
Tocolo Cantina
OFF PREMISE CATERER
Bagel Boss
Ben’s Kosher Deli
Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen Restaurant
& Caterers
BrickHouse Brewery
Delicious Moments Caterers
Exquisite Eats Catering
Fattusco’s Gourmet
Iavarone Bros.
Jonathan Scinto
Little Kitchen Creations by Wendy
LL Dent
Lobster Roll
Lombardi’s Gourmet Market
Seaqua Delicatessen and Caterers
Sempre Fame Gourmet Catering–
Floral Park
Vincent’s Clam Bar–Carle Place
Zorn’s–Multiple Locations
ORGANIC EATERY
Bareburger–Great Neck
Bob’s Natural Foods–Long Beach
Cornucopia Natural Foods
Dr. B. Well Naturally–Plainview
Food For Thought–Garden City
Jandi’s–Oceanside
Juice It Up–Massapequa Park
Lucky 13 Cafe–Medford
Ms. Michelle’s Urban Gourmet–
Bayport
Naturally Good Foods & Cafe–
Montauk
Organic Corner
The Health Nuts–Westbury
Tiger Lily Cafe–Port Jefferson
Tula’s Kitchen–Bay Shore
West East Bistro
Wild Side Organic Bistro & Bar
PANCAKES
CJ’s Coffee Shop
Country Kitchen–East Northport
Denny’s–Multiple Locations
East Norwich Diner
Glen’s Dinette–Babylon Village
Grand Luxe Cafe–Garden City
IHOP
International Delight Cafe–Multiple
Locations
Landmark Diner
Maureen’s Kitchen
Munday’s–Huntington
Peter Pan Diner–Bayshore
Stew Leonard’s
The CookRoom
Thomas’ Ham & Eggery–Carl Place
Wander Inn Restaurant–Baldwin
PASTRAMI SANDWICH
Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen Restaurant
& Caterers
Boswell’s Deli–Merrick
Commack Kosher–Commack
Cooky’s Deli–Bohemia
Delsen’s Kosher Delicatessen–Bay Shore
Kensington Kosher Deli–Great Neck
Lido Kosher Deli–Long Beach
Pastrami King–Merrick
Pastrami N Friends–Commack
Pastrami Plus–East Meadow
Regal Kosher Deli & Caterers–
Plainview
Roast Sandwich House–Melville
Traditions Eatery–Lawrence
PIZZA
Brucie’s Bel-Aire Pizzeria
NOMINEE PROFILES
RUFFINO’S
Ruffino’s has been twisting soft, salty dough into the knots patrons love
to dip in mustard or drench in hot, melty cheese for years, amassing a
loyal following at the Tri County Flea Market. They offer an assortment
of toppings, including butter, bacon and cheddar, cream cheese, regular
and salted. Each bite yields a warm, soft chew that fills the belly and
warms the heart only the way the very best comfort foods can. And these
pretzel creations are huge. Ruffino’s didn’t grow this popular by skimping
out—evident by each and every substantial portion they serve. Patrons are
guaranteed to crave another almost immediately, and at Ruffino’s walletfriendly
prices, justified to go back again and again for more.
NOMINEE PROFILES
THE FISH STORE
The Fish Store in Bayport is a respected gem of the South Shore. One
half is a fish shop, offering the very freshest just-off-the-boat fish, such as
fluke and flounder, clams and oysters, lobster and shrimp. The other half
is a cozy restaurant decorated in seafaring memorabilia. Their menu offers
hearty chowders and bisques, clams and oysters on the half shell, fried,
stuffed, or baked, tons of appetizers, sandwiches and entrees. They also
have an extensive sushi menu on Thursdays. This family owned and operated
establishment has been a mainstay in Bayport for almost 40 years.
Beyond offering a wide array of seafood options, the staff is knowledgeable
and helpful, always on hand to give advice about how to prepare
your catch at home. And the prices are unbeatable. Join them for seasonal
dinners, such as the Fall Harvest Wine Dinner, with courses paired with locally
procured wine. If you’re looking for seafood, The Fish Store is a real
catch. Learn more at www.thefishstoreonline.com.
Fattusco’s Gourmet
Frantoni’s Pizzeria
Gino’s of West Hempstead
Gino’s Pizza
Joe’s Pizza and Pasta–Holbrook
Mario’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
Massa’s Coal Fired Pizzeria
Michael Anthony’s Pizza
Mr G’S
Papa Ciro’s
Plum Tomatoes Pizzeria Restaurant
Red Tomato
Rosas of Massapequa
Umbertos of Wantagh
Vito’s Ristorante & Pizzeria–Glen
Cove
RIBS
Adam’s Rib–Massapequa
Bell’s Kitchen and Smokehouse
Big Daddy’s Restaurant–Massapequa
Bobbique–Patchogue
Famous Dave’s–Multiple Locations
J&R’s Steakhouse–Multiple Locations
Piccolo of Huntington
Popei’s Clam Bar
Rookies Sports Club
Sempre Fame Gourmet BBQ and
Catering
Smokey Bones–Ronkonkoma
24 BETHPAGE BEST OF LONG ISLAND 2018 • VOTERS GUIDE • BESTOFLONGISLAND.COM
Smokin’ Al’s
Spiro’s Restaurant & Lounge
Storyville American Table
Swingbelly’s BBQ–Long Beach
Wings Plus
RICE BALL
Calda Pizzeria–Hicksville
Ciao Baby
Fattusco’s Gourmet
Gino’s of Tuscany Bellmore–North Bellmore
Gregorio’s Pizzeria & Trattoria
Joe’s Pizza and Pasta–Holbrook
La Capannina–Holtsville
Mario’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
Michael Anthony’s Pizza
Parmagianni
Pizzatini
Ruvo Restaurant East–Port Jefferson
Vespa Italian Kitchen & Bar
Villa Maria Pizzeria
Vito’s Ristorante & Pizzeria
Zona
RICE PUDDING
Athenian Greek Taverna
Bagel Basket Cafe–Commack
Blackbirds’ Grille–Sayville
Empress Diner–East Meadow
Forum Diner–Bay Shore
Iavarone Bros.–Multiple Locations
Landmark Diner–Roslyn
Nancy the Cupcake Lady
New York Natural Pudding Co.–
Westbury
Peter Pan Diner–Bayshore
Reel Restaurant–East Rockaway
Santorini Greek Restaurant–Merrick
Sea Basin Restaurant
Spiro’s Restaurant & Lounge
Sweet ‘n’ Savory–Port Jefferson
The Greek Place
SALAD
BrickHouse Brewery
Cino’s Bagels Bethpage
Cino’s Hot Bagels Oceanside
FOOD
NOMINEE PROFILES
VITO’S
Whether it’s a mouth-watering slice or a full, home-cooked feast, Vito’s
Ristorante in Glen Cove is where to go for high-quality Italian food
served in a relaxing environment by friendly and considerate staff. Vito’s
offers classics, such as pepperoni and sausage slices, to specialties
including spicy and tangy Buffalo chicken slices, to many more. Vito’s
also serves pasta dishes, such as penne with sausage and artichokes
and rigatoni alla vodka, various deliciously stuffed heroes, and plenty
of delectable side dishes, such as their famous rice ball. Vito himself is
always on hand to offer extra plates, sauces, answer questions, or just
greet you and your family with a warm, welcoming smile.